Gearbox and transmission problems are among the most expensive faults you can encounter – often £2,000 to £5,000+ to repair. When these issues appear shortly after buying a car, you have strong grounds for rejection.
Types of Transmission Problems
Manual gearbox issues typically present as difficulty selecting gears (often caused by worn synchros or linkage), grinding during changes from synchromesh failure, jumping out of gear due to worn selector forks, whining or rumbling from bearing failure, and oil leaks from deteriorating seals.
Automatic gearbox issues include slipping between gears from worn clutch packs, delayed engagement caused by valve body or solenoid problems, harsh shifting from hydraulic or electronic faults, shuddering due to torque converter problems, and in the worst cases, complete internal failure.
DSG and dual-clutch transmissions (VW DSG, Ford PowerShift, and similar) have their own characteristic problems. Low-speed juddering from clutch pack wear is extremely common, along with hesitation when pulling away due to mechatronic unit failure, jerky gear changes from clutch or software issues, and total loss of gears when the mechatronic unit fails completely.
Clutch problems on manual cars range from slipping (worn clutch disc) and juddering on take-off (contaminated or warped disc) to a high biting point indicating wear approaching failure and noise when the pedal is pressed from a failing release bearing.
Which Gearboxes Are Known for Problems?
The VW Group DQ200 dry clutch DSG – found across the VW Golf, Polo, and Passat, Audi A1 and A3, Seat Leon and Ibiza, and Skoda Octavia and Fabia – is one of the most problematic transmissions on the market. The 7-speed dry clutch unit has well-documented issues with juddering, hesitation, and mechatronic failures. If you own a VW with DSG problems, see our Volkswagen DSG gearbox fault guide for specific advice.
The Ford PowerShift (DPS6), fitted to the Ford Fiesta (2011-2017) and Focus (2011-2016), has been the subject of class actions in other countries. It's known for shuddering, slipping, and unexpected loss of power.
The Renault EDC, found in the Clio, Captur, and Megane, suffers from clutch and mechatronic issues similar to other dual-clutch designs. BMW automatic transmissions are generally reliable, though some models experience ZF 8-speed mechatronic issues or torque converter shudder.
Your Consumer Rights
The Legal Standard
Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, the car must be of satisfactory quality (Section 9), fit for purpose (Section 10), and durable enough for its age and mileage. A gearbox that fails or causes significant issues shortly after purchase fails these standards.
Gearboxes are major components designed to last the lifetime of the vehicle – often 150,000 miles or more. Failure at lower mileage points to pre-existing wear or damage, a manufacturing defect, or a fundamental lack of durability. Any of these makes the car unsatisfactory under the Act.
The 6-Month Rule
Within 6 months of purchase, any fault is presumed present at sale. The dealer must prove the gearbox was fine when sold – which is difficult to prove.
Think you might have a claim?
Check if you're entitled to a refund under the Consumer Rights Act. Free, takes 2 minutes.
Building Your Case
Get a diagnostic report from a gearbox specialist or independent inspector. Ask them to confirm the fault, identify the likely cause, estimate how long the problem was developing, and comment on whether the issue would have been present or detectable at the point of sale.
Check the MOT history on gov.uk for previous advisories about transmission noise, test failures for gearbox-related issues, and mileage patterns that show whether the car was serviced regularly. Review the service history too – gearbox oil changes are often neglected, and any previous transmission work or dealer service notes about concerns strengthen your case.
Calculate your mileage carefully: note the mileage at purchase, the current mileage, and the miles you've added. If the gearbox failed after you added 2,000 miles to a 60,000-mile car, those 2,000 miles didn't cause the problem. Keep thorough records of everything.
Clutch Claims: A Specific Challenge
Clutches are different because they are wear items. However:
You can still claim if the clutch failed at low mileage (under 60,000 miles), if it failed shortly after purchase, if there was no disclosure of clutch wear issues, or if the failure was caused by a defect rather than normal wear – for example, a manufacturing fault in the clutch assembly.
Clutches typically last 60,000-100,000 miles with normal driving. If you buy a car at 50,000 miles and the clutch fails after you've added 3,000 miles, the wear was clearly present at purchase. Professional dealers should check clutch condition before selling, and if it was near end of life, they should have either replaced it or disclosed the wear and priced the car accordingly.
Sample Rejection Letter
To: [Dealer]
Re: Rejection of Vehicle – Gearbox/Transmission Fault
Registration: [X]
Dear Sir/Madam,
On [date], I purchased [vehicle make/model] from you at [mileage] miles for £[price].
Since purchase, I have experienced [describe symptoms: jerking, slipping, grinding, warning lights, etc.]. I have had the vehicle inspected by [specialist], who confirmed [diagnosis].
This constitutes a breach of the Consumer Rights Act 2015:
-
Satisfactory Quality (Section 9) – A gearbox should provide reliable operation for the expected lifespan of the vehicle. [This type of failure / These symptoms] at [mileage] miles indicates the vehicle was not of satisfactory quality.
-
Fit for Purpose (Section 10) – The vehicle cannot safely/reliably [describe impact: be driven in traffic, accelerate normally, etc.], making it unfit for its normal purpose.
-
Durability – [Gearboxes/DSG units/Clutches on cars of this type] should last [expected lifespan]. Failure at [X] miles demonstrates lack of durability.
[If within 6 months]: Under Section 19(14), this fault is presumed to have been present at the point of sale.
I have added only [X] miles since purchase. It is not credible that my use caused this problem.
I am rejecting this vehicle and require:
- A full refund of £[amount]
- Collection of the vehicle at your expense [If applicable: 3. Cancellation of the finance agreement]
Please respond within 14 days.
Yours faithfully, [Your name]
Recommended reading
What If They Offer a Repair?
Within 30 Days
You can refuse a repair and insist on rejection within 30 days. For major components like gearboxes, rejection is often preferable – a repaired gearbox is never quite as reliable as one that was fine in the first place.
After 30 days, you must usually allow one repair attempt. Consider whether it will be a quality repair using a new or remanufactured gearbox or a bodge job, what warranty the dealer will provide on the repair, and whether you'll trust the car afterwards. If the repair fails or takes unreasonably long, you can then reject.
Finance Protection
If you used PCP, HP, or a credit card, the finance company is jointly liable under Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act. Write to them at the same time as the dealer – they may be more responsive than an evasive dealer, and you can pursue them if the dealer goes bust.
DSG/Dual-Clutch Specific Issues
For dual-clutch transmissions with known problems:
Reference the pattern – these are known problem areas. Document that the specific unit (such as the DQ200) has widespread issues, that technical service bulletins exist, that recalls or extended warranties were offered in other countries, and that forum reports and news articles detail the problem extensively. This establishes that the fault is a design or manufacturing issue, not something caused by your driving.
Be cautious about software vs hardware claims. DSG issues can sometimes be software-related, and dealers may claim a software update fixed the problem. However, underlying hardware problems often remain after a software patch, and the symptoms may return within weeks or months.
When You've Already Repaired
If you paid for a repair before realising you had rights, you may still claim the repair cost as damages. Keep all invoices and the old parts if possible. Your rejection right may be weaker since you've effectively "accepted" the goods by arranging your own repair, but you can still pursue compensation for the cost of putting right a fault that should never have been there.
The Bottom Line
Gearboxes are designed to last 150,000 miles or more, so early failure points strongly to a pre-existing defect or wear that existed before you bought the car. DSG and dual-clutch units have well-documented issues across several manufacturers, and researching your specific transmission type can strengthen your case considerably. Within 6 months, the fault is presumed present at purchase, putting the burden of proof on the dealer. Clutch claims are harder because clutches are wear items, but premature failure is still actionable – especially if the dealer didn't disclose existing wear. Get a specialist diagnosis documenting the fault and its likely cause, use finance protection through Section 75 if applicable, and don't accept poor repairs. If the repair fails, you can reject the car and claim a refund.
Gearbox or transmission failing on a car you recently bought? Check if you qualify for our rejection service – we'll help you get a refund.
Related Topics
