Extended car warranties can provide peace of mind – or they can be worthless pieces of paper. The difference often comes down to one word: "insured." Here's what you need to know to avoid being left unprotected.
Insured vs Uninsured: The Critical Difference
Insured Warranties
An insured warranty is backed by an insurance company regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). Your cover is underwritten by an actual insurer who must honour valid claims – it's a legal requirement. If claims are unfairly rejected, you can complain to the Financial Ombudsman. If the warranty company goes bust, you may be protected by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS). The FCA regulates their conduct throughout.
Uninsured Warranties
An uninsured warranty is simply a contract with the warranty company itself – no insurance backing whatsoever. It's only as good as the company's financial health. If they go bust, your warranty is worthless. You have no Financial Ombudsman recourse, no FSCS protection, and limited regulatory oversight. In practice, you're trusting a single company to honour its promises with no safety net if it doesn't.
Why Does This Matter?
When You Need to Claim
Insured warranty: The insurer is legally obligated to pay valid claims. Even if the warranty company is difficult, you can escalate to the Financial Ombudsman, who can order payment.
Uninsured warranty: Your only recourse is against the warranty company itself. If they refuse to pay, your options are limited. If they go bust, you get nothing.
Company Goes Bust
It happens more often than you'd think. In recent years, several warranty companies have collapsed:
Insured customers: May be able to claim from the insurer or receive FSCS compensation Uninsured customers: Lost their money and their cover
Think you might have a claim?
Check if you're entitled to a refund under the Consumer Rights Act. Free, takes 2 minutes.
How to Tell the Difference
Check the documents for the name of the underwriting insurance company, an insurance policy number, and an FCA registration number. If you only see the warranty company's own name with no mention of an underwriter, it's almost certainly uninsured.
Ask the seller directly: "Is this warranty insured? Which insurance company underwrites it?" Get the answer in writing – if they can't or won't tell you, that's a red flag in itself.
Verify on the FCA Register by searching for both the warranty company and the claimed underwriter. All regulated firms must be registered, and if they're not there, the claims of regulation are false.
Your Statutory Rights Come First
Whether you have a warranty or not, your Consumer Rights Act protections still apply. A warranty cannot reduce your statutory rights – it's additional protection, not a replacement. If the car was faulty when sold, that's the dealer's legal responsibility regardless of what any warranty says.
If your car develops a fault within the first 6 months, claim against the dealer first – they're legally responsible under the Consumer Rights Act. Use the warranty as a fallback if the dealer refuses, but don't let them deflect by saying "that's a warranty matter." If the car was faulty when sold, it's their problem, not a warranty issue.
Red Flags for Worthless Warranties
Excessive exclusions are the biggest warning sign. Watch for warranties that exclude all electrical faults, turbo and DPF problems, anything classed as "wear and tear" (vaguely defined), pre-existing faults, and consequential damage. Some warranties exclude so much that you're unlikely to ever claim successfully – they look comprehensive until you actually need them.
Unrealistic limits undermine what cover remains. Check the labour rate limits (if they only pay £40/hour and your garage charges £100, you pay the difference), claim limits per claim, per year, or in total, and excess amounts. A warranty with a £500 excess and a £1,000 claim limit isn't much help when you're facing a £3,000 gearbox repair.
Onerous servicing requirements can void your cover entirely. Some warranties require main dealer servicing (expensive), unrealistic service intervals, perfect record-keeping, or specific oil grades. Check these conditions are actually achievable before you rely on the warranty.
Misleading language is another red flag. Phrases like "claims management service," "repair management programme," or "mechanical breakdown assistance" often indicate uninsured products dressed up to sound like insurance. If it doesn't say "insurance" and name an underwriter, treat it with scepticism.
Popular Warranty Providers
Among the generally reputable insured providers, Warranty Direct is long-established, AA Warranty and RAC Warranty are backed by their respective brands and insured, Warrantywise is popular (though you should verify the current underwriter), and MotorEasy offers both comparison tools and its own products.
Dealer-branded warranties require careful checking – some are properly insured, but many aren't. The same applies to cheap online warranties, which may have poor cover or be entirely uninsured. Always verify the underwriting insurer on the FCA Register before committing to any warranty.
If Your Warranty Claim Is Rejected
Get the rejection in writing with the specific exclusion they're relying on, the evidence they used, and their decision-making process. Common unfair rejection reasons include citing "pre-existing fault" without any evidence, applying a vague "wear and tear" exclusion, claiming you missed a service you actually completed, or asserting you caused the damage without proof.
For insured warranties, escalation is straightforward: make a formal complaint to the warranty provider, escalate to the underwriting insurer if unresolved, and then take it to the Financial Ombudsman Service – they have real power to order payment. For uninsured warranties, your options are more limited: a formal complaint, a report to Trading Standards, and then small claims court – though success is limited if the company has few assets.
Dealer Warranties
When you buy a car, dealers often include warranty cover, but the type matters enormously. A dealer's own warranty is provided directly by the dealer, is usually uninsured, and is only as good as the dealer's commitment to honouring it. If the dealer goes bust, the warranty is worthless.
A third-party warranty comes from a separate company and may or may not be insured – always check who the actual provider is and whether they're FCA-regulated. Approved used programmes from manufacturers (like BMW Approved Used or Toyota Approved) generally include manufacturer-backed warranties that are more reliable than third-party alternatives, though they come at a price premium.
Recommended reading
Buying a Warranty: What to Ask
Before purchasing any warranty, establish the fundamentals: is it insured, and who is the underwriter? Verify the underwriter is FCA-registered. Then scrutinise the cover itself – what's actually covered, what are the key exclusions, what are the claim limits per claim and per year, what's the excess, and what's the labour rate limit? Check the servicing requirements – can you service at any VAT-registered garage, or are you tied to expensive main dealers? And finally, ask how long the claims process typically takes.
The Bottom Line
Insured warranties are backed by regulated insurers and give you genuine protection, including access to the Financial Ombudsman if claims are unfairly rejected. Uninsured warranties are only as good as the company behind them – and if that company goes bust, you get nothing. Always check the FCA Register before buying, read the exclusions carefully (many warranties exclude the most common and expensive faults), and remember that your statutory rights come first. If the car was faulty when sold, the dealer is responsible regardless of any warranty. If in doubt about a warranty's value, your statutory rights may well be enough on their own.
Warranty rejected your claim unfairly? If the car was faulty when sold, you may have a claim against the dealer instead. Check if you qualify for our rejection service.
Related Topics
